Try a FREE Board Survey and get a Benchmarked Report - Click Here

Governance Q&A

Home | Governance Q&As | Board composition and renewal | How could boards evaluate the competencies of board directors?

Search our Governance Q&A directory

How could boards evaluate the competencies of board directors?

Most board reviews should include a process to determine whether the mix of the skills and experiences on the board is appropriate to meet the current and future strategic needs of the board. A well-structured board survey, with results benchmarked against similar boards, typically facilitates this assessment.

Competencies of individual directors, as opposed to the board as a whole, are often assessed by way of a well-designed Board Skills Matrix Survey. Rigour is added to such a survey if it includes a self and a peer review component. The peer review component helps determine what other directors think of each colleague’s skills and experiences. This assessment will cover the extent to which the skills and expertise are demonstrated and add value in the boardroom. The survey will also provide potential learning and development suggestions for each director.

 

More on this topic

The board evaluates its own performance through a structured process that typically includes self-assessments, peer evaluations and sometimes external evaluations. This process helps identify areas where the board is performing well and areas that need improvement. The evaluation may cover various aspects, such as the effectiveness of meetings, the quality of decision-making, the board’s composition and its relationship with management. The results of the evaluation are used to develop action plans to address any identified issues and to enhance the board’s overall effectiveness.

Board training and development are important because they ensure that directors have the knowledge and skills necessary to fulfil their governance responsibilities effectively. Ongoing training helps directors stay informed about governance best practices, industry trends and regulatory changes. It also enhances the board’s ability to make informed decisions and provide effective oversight. Development opportunities, such as workshops, seminars and peer exchanges, can also help build a more cohesive and effective board.

Board diversity is significant because it brings a range of perspectives, experiences and ideas to the boardroom, enhancing decision-making and governance effectiveness. A diverse board is better equipped to understand and address the needs of a broader range of stakeholders, including customers, employees and the community. Diversity also helps to prevent groupthink, promotes innovation and enhances the board’s ability to navigate complex and dynamic environments.

Board evaluations are important because they provide an opportunity to assess the board’s performance, identify areas for improvement and enhance overall effectiveness. Regular evaluations help the board to reflect on its strengths and weaknesses, address any issues that may be hindering its performance and implement changes to improve governance practices. Board evaluations also promote accountability and ensure that the board is functioning in the best interest of the organisation.

Board independence is significant because it ensures that the board can provide objective oversight and make decisions that are in the best interest of the organisation, free from conflicts of interest. Independent directors bring an unbiased perspective and are less likely to be influenced by management or other stakeholders. This enhances the board’s ability to hold management accountable and make decisions that prioritize the long-term success of the organisation.

In mergers and acquisitions (M&A), the board’s role is to provide oversight and ensure that any transaction is in the best interest of the organisation and its stakeholders. The board is responsible for reviewing and approving the strategic rationale for the transaction, conducting due diligence and evaluating the financial and operational implications. The board also oversees the integration process after the transaction to ensure it delivers the expected benefits.

A board ensures accountability by setting clear expectations for management, establishing performance metrics and regularly reviewing performance against these metrics. The board should also implement policies and procedures that promote transparency and hold individuals accountable for their actions. This includes conducting regular audits, reviews and evaluations, as well as taking corrective action when necessary to address any issues that arise.

A board should conduct effectiveness surveys annually to ensure continuous improvement and to address any issues that may arise in a timely manner. Regular surveys help maintain a focus on governance excellence and allow the board to adapt to changing circumstances and challenges. By conducting surveys annually, the board can monitor progress and ensure that action plans are implemented effectively.

Got a board governance question you’d like answered for free?
Email us today.

"*" indicates required fields

Talk to a Governance Expert.  
Schedule a call